book review: The Home-Maker by Dorothy Canfield Fisher

"The story of what happens when a wife and mother puts all her efforts into the house, and not the home. Fortunately, irreparable damage is averted when Lester, the father, takes over the role of homemaker." Reads the recommendation in The Gentle Art of Domesticity for The Home-Maker by Dorothy Canfield Fisher. With that introduction the plot was pretty simple to guess. The real genius of Fisher is her spot-on psychology. She infuses each character of this little world with thoughts so much their own that they leap off the page. By the time you come to the last chapters you can almost predict how each will react next.

I loved this book. It has been added to my mental "changed my life" bookshelf. I have always assumed that parenting ought to be learned ahead of time, if at all possible, and certainly involve outside expertise. This book dumps that idea on its head. Instead offering that parenting is so much more about the discovery--rather than the marshaling--of small charges.

The Home-Maker shows plainly how some women will never truly be happy in the home, some will adore being at home, and some will straddle the domestic and world spheres. What's more they will each succeed and excel. They will each be feminine and fascinating. Without any preachiness at all The Home-Maker manages to apply the concept of "choose what you'll love and you'll never work another day" to homelife.

Fisher illustrates clearly a concept that modern society tries to ignore: parenthood involves sacrifice. Specifically the stay-at-home parent. Of course, we all know this, but we try to jump around it prattling off about taking care of ourselves, finding outside interests, broadening our horizons. Through her characters Fisher shows the different approaches one might take but she never ignores the implacable fact that being a parent involves sacrifice. This alone makes the book worth reading.

Lastly, if nothing else, The Home-Maker is a worthwhile read just for being a well-written tome of domestic literature.

Gratitudes:
  1. I am grateful for book recommendations.
  2. I am grateful for touch.
  3. I am grateful for water.
  4. I am grateful for comfortable furniture.
  5. I am grateful for kind friends.

7 Comments:

Birrell Family said...

Hi Friend!
No. I am not a stalker. I found your blog through a friend of a friend and wanted to share our line of LDS product with you and would greatly appreciate your help spreading the word to your family & friends.
Our mission is to help strengthen family life and good values by creating affordable and inspiring products, patterns, kits and gifts...
www.pebblesinmypocketLDS.blogspot.com www.pebblesinmypocket.com
Yippee! Our first SEPTEMBER CONTEST is on our blog!
Thank you! Brenda Birrell brenda@pebblesinmypocket.com 801.836.4906
ps. I like your thoughts about infertility

miss liss said...

Dear Brenda,

Thank you for your comment. Though I did for a brief time, I do not currently do product endorsements. I appreciate that you found some of the content on my site useful.

Sincerely,
Miss Liss

The Author said...

May I ask how you got the continue reading link? Thanks!

Anna said...

What a coincidence! I read this book by "accident", thinking it was another book. I'm so glad I continued reading it, though. My mom was just like the mom in the story, and I've always wondered what was 'wrong' with her because she didn't love housework like I do. But- it also made me realize how moms sacrifice their kids souls by working. In the end, it was Lester who shaped the children and won their hearts. It could have been someone less desirable.
Even though the mom was happy, she still didn't care about the children like Lester did.

This was a very sobering, thought-provoking book. I'm glad you reminded me of it- perhaps it was not a freak thing that I happened to read it.

miss liss said...

@The Author:

There's an icon on the toolbar in Blogger in Draft (draft.blogger.com) that looks like a piece of paper with a zigzag through the middle. It's the "read more" button. I just click on it where I want it in the post. The coding to place in the blog template is found on the blogger help page. If you don't use blogger you might do a search for "Read More code".

By the way, when you use the "read more" coding make sure that it doesn't break up your formatting code. Otherwise your sidebar will slide to the bottom of the page.

Thanks for stopping by.

@Anna: I prefer to think of things showing up in my life when I need them. I do think that Evangeline cared about her children like Lester did - but she did not understand them the way he did. Where Evangeline cared that the children were well-brought up, fed well, and clothed well Lester cared that their personalities blossomed.

Thanks for your comment.

Sofia Deyanira said...

I am going to read this book this winter, thanks Lissie!

marion said...

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I dont know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

Lucy

http://businesseshome.net